An Edinburgh Foodie's Diary: 7 Dishes You Must Eat

A Culinary Journey Through Scotland's Capital

Edinburgh's food scene is a fascinating blend of ancient traditions and modern innovation, where centuries-old recipes share menu space with contemporary culinary creativity. As locals who've spent years exploring every corner of the city's dining landscape, we've identified seven dishes that truly capture the essence of eating in Edinburgh.

🥘 1. Haggis, Neeps & Tatties (Where to find the best)

Let's address the elephant in the room immediately. Yes, haggis contains organ meat. No, that shouldn't stop you from trying Scotland's national dish. When prepared properly, haggis is a revelation—richly spiced, surprisingly delicate, and far more appealing than its reputation suggests.

The Scotch Whisky Experience

While primarily a tourist attraction, the Scotch Whisky Experience on the Royal Mile serves what many consider the definitive version of this classic combination. Their haggis is made using a traditional recipe, with the perfect blend of spices that enhance rather than mask the flavors.

The "neeps and tatties" (mashed turnips and potatoes) are prepared separately but served together, allowing you to experience each component individually before combining them. The whisky pairings available elevate the entire experience from simple meal to cultural education.

The Amber Restaurant

For a more upscale interpretation, The Amber Restaurant in the Scotch Whisky Experience building offers gourmet haggis preparations that respect tradition while embracing modern techniques. Their version uses locally sourced ingredients and is served with whisky-infused cream sauce that transforms the humble dish into fine dining.

Local Pub Recommendation: The Royal Oak

For the most authentic experience, head to The Royal Oak on Infirmary Street. This traditional Scottish pub serves generous portions of honest, unpretentious haggis alongside local ales. The atmosphere is genuinely Scottish, with regular folk music sessions that provide the perfect soundtrack to your meal.

🍲 2. Cullen Skink

This thick, creamy soup made from smoked haddock, potatoes, and onions represents the very best of Scottish comfort food. Originating from the fishing village of Cullen in Moray, this hearty soup has become a staple across Scotland, with Edinburgh's chefs putting their own spins on the classic recipe.

The Shore Bar & Restaurant, Leith

Located in Edinburgh's historic port district, The Shore serves what many consider the city's finest Cullen skink. Their version respects traditional preparation methods while using the highest quality smoked haddock from sustainable Scottish fisheries.

The restaurant's waterfront location adds authenticity to the experience—you're eating a fisherman's soup while overlooking the waters where similar fish were once landed. The portion is substantial enough to serve as a meal, accompanied by fresh crusty bread and Scottish butter.

Ondine

This seafood specialist on George IV Bridge elevates Cullen skink to fine dining status without losing its soul. Their version uses the finest Arbroath smokies and is finished with a touch of cream and fresh herbs. The presentation is elegant, but the flavors remain authentically Scottish.

What Makes Great Cullen Skink

The key to exceptional Cullen skink lies in three elements: quality smoked fish, proper potato texture (creamy but not overly smooth), and the balance between smoke and cream flavors. The best versions allow you to taste the sea in every spoonful while providing the warmth and comfort that makes this soup perfect for Edinburgh's often chilly weather.

🐟 3. The Perfect Scottish Salmon

Scotland produces some of the world's finest salmon, and Edinburgh's restaurants showcase this ingredient in ways that highlight its natural excellence. Whether smoked, grilled, or cured, Scottish salmon offers a taste of the Highland waters where it's raised.

Fhior

This Michelin-starred restaurant on Broughton Street serves Scottish salmon preparations that are works of art. Their cured salmon is aged for precisely the right amount of time to develop complex flavors while maintaining the fish's natural sweetness. Served with seasonal vegetables and innovative sauces, each plate tells the story of Scottish waters and contemporary culinary technique.

The Fishmarket Bar & Grill

For a more casual but equally impressive experience, The Fishmarket on North Castle Street offers simply grilled Scottish salmon that lets the fish speak for itself. Their suppliers source directly from Scottish fish farms, ensuring freshness and traceability.

The restaurant's approach emphasizes proper cooking technique—the salmon arrives with crispy skin and perfectly flaky flesh, accompanied by seasonal vegetables that complement rather than compete with the star ingredient.

Traditional Smoked Salmon Experience

For the most traditional preparation, visit one of Edinburgh's specialty food shops like Iain Mellis Cheesemonger or George Mewes Cheese. Their smoked salmon is prepared using traditional methods, often over oak chips that impart subtle smoky flavors without overwhelming the fish's natural taste.

🍓 4. Cranachan

This traditional Scottish dessert combines whipped cream, honey, whisky, raspberries, and toasted oats into something that's both rustic and sophisticated. Created originally as a harvest festival treat, cranachan represents the best of Scottish ingredients in perfect harmony.

The Witchery by the Castle

The gothic atmosphere of The Witchery provides the perfect setting for this traditional dessert. Their cranachan is prepared tableside in some cases, allowing you to watch the layers come together. The restaurant uses Heather honey and single malt whisky, creating a version that's both authentic and luxurious.

Restaurant Martin Wishart

The Michelin-starred chef's interpretation of cranachan elevates the humble dessert to fine dining standards while respecting its rustic origins. The presentation is elegant, but the flavors remain true to Scottish tradition. Fresh raspberries are sourced from local farms when in season, and the oats are toasted to perfect golden crispiness.

Making It Special

Great cranachan depends on the balance between sweetness and alcohol, the texture contrast between smooth cream and crunchy oats, and the quality of each individual component. The best versions taste like the Scottish Highlands in dessert form—wild, sophisticated, and utterly satisfying.

🍫 5. A Deep-Fried Mars Bar (Yes, really!)

Perhaps no dish is more associated with Scottish cuisine's quirky reputation than the deep-fried Mars bar. While it might sound like a joke, this creation is taken seriously by many Edinburgh chip shops and has become a genuine part of local food culture.

The Chippy Doon the Lane

This traditional fish and chip shop on Antigua Street serves what locals consider the gold standard deep-fried Mars bar. The batter is light and crispy, the chocolate becomes molten without being overwhelmingly sweet, and the entire experience is surprisingly sophisticated.

The key is the batter recipe—too heavy and it overwhelms the chocolate; too light and it doesn't provide enough contrast. The Chippy has perfected their technique over years of practice, creating something that's indulgent without being cloying.

Understanding the Appeal

The deep-fried Mars bar isn't just about excess—it's about the contrast between hot and cold, sweet and salty, soft and crispy. When executed properly, it's a dessert that challenges preconceptions while delivering genuine pleasure. The warm batter gives way to molten chocolate and soft nougat, creating textures and temperatures that wouldn't be possible without the frying process.

Many visitors try it as a novelty but leave understanding why it's become a legitimate part of Scottish cuisine. It represents Scottish cooking at its most inventive—taking an everyday item and transforming it into something unexpectedly delicious.

🥧 6. A Proper Scotch Pie

The Scotch pie is a masterclass in pastry engineering—a small, round pie with a crispy pastry shell that holds seasoned minced mutton (sometimes beef) and is topped with pastry that creates a well for adding beans, mashed potatoes, or gravy.

Clarks Bakery

Multiple locations across Edinburgh serve what many consider the city's finest Scotch pies. Their pastry is properly crispy without being tough, and the filling is well-seasoned without being oversalted. The pies are baked fresh throughout the day, ensuring you'll get one at peak quality.

The Proper Way to Eat One

Scotch pies are designed to be eaten hot, ideally straight from the bakery. Many locals add a dollop of brown sauce or tomato sauce, while traditionalists prefer them unadorned. The pastry should crack satisfyingly when bitten, releasing the savory steam from the meat filling.

They're perfect stadium food, pub snacks, or quick lunches, representing Scottish practicality at its finest. The best versions achieve the perfect balance between pastry and filling, with enough seasoning to make the meat flavorful without overpowering its natural taste.

🍰 7. Sticky Toffee Pudding

While not exclusively Scottish, sticky toffee pudding has been adopted wholeheartedly by Edinburgh's dessert culture. This moist sponge cake made with dates and covered in toffee sauce represents the kind of comfort food that's perfect for Scotland's climate.

The Elephant House

Famous as one of the cafés where J.K. Rowling wrote parts of Harry Potter, The Elephant House also serves exceptional sticky toffee pudding. Their version is properly moist without being soggy, and the toffee sauce strikes the perfect balance between sweet and bitter.

Served with proper custard or vanilla ice cream, it's the kind of dessert that makes you understand why British comfort food has such a devoted following. The café's literary connections add to the experience—you're enjoying dessert in a space that helped create one of the world's most beloved stories.

Deacon's House Café

This Royal Mile institution serves sticky toffee pudding in portions that are generous without being overwhelming. Their recipe has been refined over years of service, creating a dessert that's both traditional and exceptional.

What Makes It Special

Great sticky toffee pudding requires perfect timing—the sponge must be moist but not heavy, the toffee sauce warm but not burning hot, and the accompaniments (custard or ice cream) cold enough to provide temperature contrast. When all elements come together properly, it's a dessert that embodies everything appealing about British comfort food.

🌟 Beyond the Dishes: The Edinburgh Food Experience

These seven dishes represent more than just flavors—they're windows into Edinburgh's culture, history, and character. Each has its own story, its own devoted following, and its own perfect moment for consumption.

What unites them is their authenticity to place. You can't experience these flavors properly anywhere else in the world. They require Scottish ingredients, Scottish techniques, and the Scottish approach to hospitality that makes each meal feel like a cultural exchange.

🍽️ Tips for Food Adventurers

• ▸
  Ask locals for recommendations: The best versions of these dishes are often found in places that don't advertise to tourists.
• ▸
  Be adventurous: Don't let preconceptions prevent you from trying something new.
• ▸
  Respect the traditions: These dishes exist for good reasons—approach them with curiosity rather than skepticism.
• ▸
  Try them in their proper settings: A Scotch pie tastes different when eaten in a traditional pub versus a tourist restaurant.
• ▸
  Don't rush: Take time to appreciate the craftsmanship and history behind each dish.